The Thanksgiving I Finally Got Right

The Thanksgiving I Finally Got Right

By Joe Durst | Rough Edges Magazine

The first Thanksgiving after Amanda left, I decided I was going to cook Tucker a traditional Thanksgiving dinner.

The whole goddamn thing.

Turkey. Stuffing. Mashed potatoes. Gravy. Green beans. Sweet potatoes. Pumpkin pie.

I was going to do it all.

Looking back, I should've just taken the boy to Denny's.

But no. I had something to prove.

Not to Amanda. Not to anybody else, really.

To myself.

I was going to show that kid that just because his mother wasn't there anymore didn't mean he was going to miss out on anything.

And apparently, in my forty-something-year-old brain, that meant buying a turkey roughly the size of a Buick engine and attempting to cook six different things at the same time.

I've already written about what a pain in the ass Thanksgiving is.

Well, this is how I became an expert on the subject.

Martha Stewart Can Kiss My Ass

Let me explain something.

I'm a contractor.

Give me a pile of lumber, a box of screws, and a set of plans, and I'll build you something that'll still be standing twenty years from now.

Give me a frozen turkey and tell me dinner needs to be ready at two o'clock?

You're taking your chances.

I had no idea what the hell I was doing.

I figured I'd just follow the directions.

How hard could it be?

Well, for starters, nobody bothered telling me that a frozen turkey needs approximately eleven weeks to thaw.

I bought the damn thing a couple days before Thanksgiving, stuck it in the refrigerator, and figured that was that.

Thursday morning, I pulled it out.

Solid as a rock.

I could've used that son of a bitch to pound fence posts.

So there I stood at the kitchen sink, running cold water over a frozen bird while Tucker wandered in wearing his pajamas.

"Dad, what are you doing?"

"Cooking Thanksgiving dinner."

He looked at the turkey.

Then he looked at me.

"Okay."

And walked away.

Smart kid.

He knew better than to get involved.

I eventually got the thing into the oven.

Then I started on everything else.

The potatoes boiled over.

I couldn't find the can opener.

I had no idea whether the stuffing was supposed to go inside the turkey or in a separate pan.

And at some point, I discovered a little bag of unidentified turkey parts that apparently had been hiding inside the bird.

What the hell was I supposed to do with those?

I threw them away.

Whatever they were, we weren't eating them.

By two o'clock, the potatoes were cold, the gravy looked like something you'd use to patch drywall, and the turkey still wasn't done.

Tucker was standing in the pantry eating crackers.

"You're going to spoil your dinner," I told him.

He looked at me.

"When is dinner?"

Fair question.

We eventually ate sometime that evening.

I don't remember exactly when.

I do remember sitting at the table looking at all that food and wondering why the hell I'd put myself through it.

And the worst part?

Tucker barely touched the turkey.

I Kept Doing It Anyway

You'd think I would've learned something from that experience.

Nope.

The following year, I tried again.

New turkey. New recipes. New opportunity to completely fuck up my kitchen.

I even made a schedule.

Imagine that.

A grown man who can coordinate subcontractors, material deliveries, inspections, and construction deadlines sitting at his kitchen table figuring out what time to put the sweet potatoes in the oven.

And still getting it wrong.

Something was always late.

Something was always cold.

Something was always burning while I was trying to rescue something else.

And there was Tucker, sitting around waiting for his father to finish proving whatever the hell he thought he needed to prove.

I don't think the boy ever complained.

That's what makes me feel like such an idiot looking back.

He wasn't asking for any of it.

I was doing it because I had this picture in my head of what Thanksgiving was supposed to look like.

A family around the table.

A big dinner.

Everything just right.

And because our family didn't look the way it used to, I thought I had to make up the difference with mashed potatoes.

Jesus Christ.

The things we convince ourselves of.

The Kid Finally Set Me Straight

Eventually, I started asking Tucker what he actually wanted for Thanksgiving.

Not what he thought we were supposed to eat.

What he wanted.

Turns out the kid didn't have particularly strong feelings about turkey.

He liked mashed potatoes.

He liked a decent piece of meat.

He liked having something good for dessert.

And he liked spending time with his dad.

Well, hell.

I could handle that.

We started making simpler dinners.

Sometimes we'd have ham.

Sometimes hamburgers.

Sometimes I'd cook something that had absolutely no business being called Thanksgiving dinner.

And you know what?

Nobody gave a shit.

We ate when we were hungry.

The food was hot.

I wasn't standing in the kitchen cussing at a roasting pan.

And Tucker wasn't spending half the afternoon wondering when his father was going to emerge from the oven.

We'd eat, watch television, talk about whatever was going on, and generally enjoy ourselves.

Imagine that.

Actually enjoying Thanksgiving.

What a revolutionary fucking concept.

I eventually got comfortable enough in the kitchen to put together my own Bachelor Cookbook. Nothing fancy. Just food a regular guy can make without needing a culinary degree or a second mortgage.

You can find it withmy other books.

But it took me a while to understand that being a good father had absolutely nothing to do with being able to cook a turkey.

And Tucker wasn't the only kid who helped teach me that.

A Few More Kids Around the Table

Funny thing is, Tucker wasn't the only kid I ever worried about getting things right for.

There were others.

Quite a few others, actually.

Over the years, thirteen foster kids came through my house.

I haven't talked much about that part of my life. Not because it's some big secret. It just isn't something that comes up when you're telling people how to build a deck or complaining about the price of groceries.

And before anybody starts telling me what a wonderful guy I must be, don't.

I wasn't saving the world.

I was just a guy with a house, a kid of his own, and a pretty good idea of what it felt like to be a little boy who needed somebody.

I'd spent some time in foster care myself when I was young.

That's another story for another day.

But I remembered enough of it to know that there were kids out there who needed more than somebody feeling sorry for them.

They needed a place to live. Somebody who'd feed them. Somebody who'd show up when they got in trouble at school.

Start with Thanksgiving Is a Pain in the Ass

Somebody who gave a shit.

And I figured I could be that somebody.

Well, hell.

I might've been a little too enthusiastic about the whole thing.

Because at one point, I had Tucker and three foster boys living under the same roof.

Four boys.

One house.

One bathroom that never seemed to have any toilet paper.

And one exhausted contractor who apparently thought he was fucking Superman.

I knew I was taking on too much. I knew it while I was doing it.

But I figured I'd make it work.

That's been one of my problems in life. I get something in my head, decide I'm going to do it, and then worry about whether it was a good idea after I'm already knee-deep in the shit.

And those boys gave me plenty to worry about.

They also gave me some of the best memories I've got.

Four Boys and One Very Tired Contractor

You want to know what life looks like with four boys in one house?

Forget those heartwarming television commercials where everybody's sitting around the table smiling.

That's not what I remember.

I remember buying milk and wondering how the hell two gallons disappeared before I'd even had a glass.

I remember shoes everywhere.

Towels on the bathroom floor.

Somebody yelling because somebody else touched something that apparently belonged to him.

I remember walking through the front door after ten hours on a job and hearing "Joe!" or "Dad!" before I even had my boots off.

And everybody needed something.

Right then.

One kid needed help with homework.

Another was pissed off about something that happened at school.

Somebody was hungry.

Somebody couldn't find his shoes.

And Tucker, who'd already spent his entire life putting up with me, had his own things going on.

There were days I handled it pretty well.

There were days I wanted to get back in my truck, drive around the block, and pretend I couldn't find the house.

But there were good days, too.

A lot of them.

And there were moments that made the aggravation worth it.

Little things.

A kid laughing at something stupid.

Somebody falling asleep on the couch.

A boy who'd been through more shit than any child should have to deal with finally relaxing enough to act like a regular kid.

You don't forget those things.

At least I haven't.

The Little Boy Who Kept Stealing My Hat

There was one boy in particular.

I'll call him David.

He was about ten when he came to live with us.

And that little bastard had a habit of stealing my hat.

Now, anybody who knows me knows I wear a hat damn near everywhere.

Usually camouflage.

Bent bill.

Nothing fancy.

I'd come home, sit down on the couch, take my hat off, and set it beside me.

A few minutes later, I'd look over.

Gone.

And there'd be David, sitting right next to me with my hat on his head.

Usually pulled down so far he could barely see.

I'd look at him.

He'd look at me.

"Where'd you get that hat?"

He'd grin.

"Found it."

"Yeah? Where?"

"Right there."

And he'd point to the spot where I'd left it.

Well, hell.

Couldn't argue with that.

He liked sitting beside me.

And when I say beside me, I mean right the hell beside me.

We could have an entire couch available, and he'd be pressed up against my arm like we were trying to fit six people on an airplane.

Sometimes he'd reach over and pat me on the shoulder.

Not because he wanted anything.

Just a couple of pats.

Then he'd go back to watching television.

I got used to it.

Matter of fact, I liked it.

There was something about that boy.

He could be a handful.

Believe me.

But there were times when he'd sit there wearing my hat, watching television, perfectly content just to be beside me.

And I'd think about how little it sometimes takes to make a kid happy.

Not a new bicycle.

Not a trip to Disney World.

Not a table full of expensive food.

Sometimes all a kid wants is a place to sit where he feels like he belongs.

And somebody who doesn't mind him being there.

What I Finally Figured Out

I started this whole thing talking about Thanksgiving.

And somehow I've ended up telling you about thirteen foster kids and a little boy who used to steal my hat.

That's usually how my mind works.

But there's a reason.

For years, I thought being a good father meant making sure Tucker had everything he was supposed to have.

The holidays.

The presents.

The big dinners.

The family traditions.

All the things I thought a normal childhood was supposed to include.

And I drove myself nuts trying to provide them.

Then I had children come through my house who'd never had much of anything.

Some of them didn't care what we ate.

Some didn't know what a normal family dinner was supposed to look like.

They just wanted to know whether somebody was going to be there tomorrow.

Whether the house was safe.

Whether they were welcome.

And whether the grown man sitting on the couch was going to get pissed off if they borrowed his hat.

That's when I started understanding how badly I'd been overcomplicating things.

I can't tell you which Thanksgiving was the one I finally got right.

There wasn't some magical dinner where everything suddenly fell into place.

It happened gradually.

I stopped worrying so much about what was on the table and started paying more attention to who was sitting around it.

And I wish I could tell you I got everything right after that.

I didn't.

Not even close.

There are decisions I made as a foster father that I still think about.

Things I wish I'd handled differently.

And one little boy whose name comes to mind more often than the others.

David.

The kid who wore my hat like it belonged to him.

There's a lot more to his story.

Some of it's funny.

Some of it isn't.

And some of it I've carried around for years without really knowing what to do with it.

I think I'm finally ready to tell it.

Read: My Other Son

This next story is a personal feature for paid Rough Edges members.


Joe Durst is a construction contractor, single father, and writer. He's gotten considerably better at cooking over the years, although he still believes a hamburger is a perfectly respectable Thanksgiving dinner.